Kent Kramer, CFP, AIF, is chief investment officer/lead adviser at Foster Group. He writes about investing for IowaBiz.com.
Like many Americans, I keep looking out my window for pigs with wings ... the euphemism “when pigs fly” having been recently invoked for:
- The Chicago Cubs winning the World Series after a 108-year drought, finding themselves down three games to one to the Cleveland Indians on Oct. 30 (15% probability*).
- Donald Trump winning the United States presidential election after an aggregated index of national polls gave him less than a 3-in-10 chance to win on Nov. 8 (28.6% probability*).
- U.S. stock market indices reaching all-time highs within 24 hours of Nov. 8's unexpected election results, given the plummeting futures markets as election returns were tallied in the early morning hours of Nov. 9. (Dow futures down over 5% at 1:30 a.m. EST 11/9/2016.+)
For each of these three outcomes, the odds against them occurring were very long. In other words, those professions specializing in making predictions (bookies, pollsters, certain hedge funds) ended up being wrong in historically significant ways.
In the days leading up to the recent election, I had the opportunity to speak with a number of audiences and investors about what (if anything) the coming election meant for financial markets and portfolios. As tempting as it was to make a prediction, after 22 years of observing investment market behavior as a “professional,” I resisted, knowing that the odds of making anything like a correct prediction were no better than 50-50.
Sports fans, political observers and many investors can’t seem to help themselves when it comes to the temptation of making predictions. We watch the news, talk with friends and colleagues, read the pundits, editorials and analysis, and we believe that we can “see the writing on the wall.” While it’s fun to do this with our sports loyalties, it’s potentially disastrous to act on our predictions when it comes to portfolios.
There were professional and institutional investors on the wrong side of that 5% fall in the value of Dow futures. They were predicting a very negative impact on U.S. stocks as a result of the surprising election outcome. However, as U.S. markets began the trading day Wednesday morning following the election, the Dow Jones industrials index opened down a minuscule 0.08% and closed the day up 1.4% at a new record high+. Taking investment actions in line with those negative predictions in the early hours proved very costly.
In a recent white paper on the benefits of diversification, researcher Wei Dai, Ph.D., finds that under many conditions diversification not only reduces volatility, but, “For all investment horizons, there was a substantial increase in the reliability of outperformance as the portfolios become more diversified.”++ Dai was researching U.S. stock portfolio strategies formed around varying degrees of overweighting to value and smaller company stocks and how taking a more or less diversified approach affected results.
For investors who are thinking about how to position their portfolios for higher probabilities of outperformance, Dai’s conclusion supports the idea that consistent diversification over longer time periods is a more reliable strategy for both reducing risk and enhancing return than acting on short-term predictive models using timing models and smaller numbers of stocks.
* Both according to FiveThirtyEight.com a leading statistical modeling website for sports, politics and economics.
+ Wall Street Journal, Nov. 9, 2016
++ "How Diversification Affects the Reliability of Outcomes," Wei Dai, Ph.D., Dimensional Fund Advisors LP
PLEASE NOTE LIMITATIONS: Please see Important Disclosure Information and the limitations of any ranking/recognitions, at www.fostergrp.com/disclosures. The above discussion should be viewed in its entirety. The use of any portion thereof without reference to the remainder could result in a loss of context. Foster Group cannot be responsible for any resulting discrepancy. A copy of our current written disclosure statement as set forth on Part 2A of Form ADV is available at www.adviserinfo.sec.gov.